"Type 3" Services

Optimising advertising space

In the early days of the Internet, advertising was not very profitable because it was poorly targeted. One remembers the 2000s, when a web page might be 90% flashing banners (or “pop-up” windows) and 10% “useful content”. That hurt the service publisher and was unpleasant for the user.

It became clear that advertising had to be better targeted to make it less intrusive. The Internet can individualise content with a precision unmatched by traditional media. Online, every user is unique and can be shown the content most “suited” to them. To do that, one must know the user — and therefore collect personal data on each of them. “Type 3” services were born from that observation.

The result was striking: within a few years, web pages sharply reduced the space given over to ads. Users got a much better experience on “Type 2” services, which earned more because the ads they displayed were far more effective. Even “Type 1” services sold more.

At what cost?

People say: “If it’s free, you are the product.” More precisely, for “Type 3” services the product is users’ data. That business model underpins companies that are now among the largest market capitalisations in the world.

Everything is done to attract users (promotions and network effects) and to stop them from leaving (by raising the cost of exit, by creating addiction). That tends to produce “silos” between which a lack of interoperability is deliberate.

This data describes each user: tastes, habits, desires, health, age group, political, religious or sexual orientation, and so on. Taken together, the data collected on a user builds a profile far more precise than anything they could say about themselves if asked.

Those profiles are then sold on to anyone who can profit from them: advertisers for targeting, insurers for risk assessment (and thus premiums), politicians for political marketing (or even mass manipulation).

When there is also collusion with states — and that happens in democracies as well — mass surveillance becomes possible, with an immediate side effect of widespread self-censorship (what English speakers call a “chilling effect”).